The Reckoning

I am unable to understand why a society that complains of unemployment should encourage and embrace every conceivable possibility of replacing human labor by mechanical devices.1

We are suffering, not from the rheumatics of old age, but from the growing-pains of over-rapid changes, from the painfulness of readjustment between one economic period and another…We are being afflicted with a new disease…namely, technological unemployment.2

I don’t understand what’s happening to my country.3

Over the holiday, I found myself driving along U.S. Route 220 in Virginia, about an hour north of the hometown of Dean Price, one of the central characters of The Unwinding.  As I traveled that road, which I’d cruised down several times before, I was reminded of Packer’s chronicling of the decline of the textiles and tobacco industries in the Carolina Piedmont, and how in a very real way, America has been gutted.



These charts are but a selective snapshot of the dynamics that took place over the previous two decades.  You could choose others; highlighting, say, that nearly one in three U.S. manufacturing jobs disappeared (~ 5 million positions), with socioeconomic knock-on effects on cities and households across the country.

There is a constellation of narratives for this decay—globalization, outsourcing, information technology, NAFTA, China, stock option incentive plans, quarterly profit targets, unions, immigration, Reagan, regulation, Wall Street, Wal-Mart—providing ready explanations that conform with one’s ideological predilections.5  But one ineluctable conclusion is that politics failed to ease citizens’ transitions as they navigated the structural changes taking place in the U.S. and global economies.

The Last Leg

As households bore the burdens of adjustment themselves, the policy decisions (and indecisions) in the wake of the global financial crisis revealed a skew toward the interests of big business and the megabanks.  While the rationale for the policy decisions may have been sound, the outcomes have been greater inequality, perceptions of less opportunity, and a crisis of accountability (see charts below; click to enlarge).



Barring unforeseen catalysts, the continuing squeeze of labor is likely to exacerbate inequality while diminishing broad-based economic opportunity.  These trends are unsustainable.  It’s not hard to imagine a stratification of the body politic into a camp that pushes aggressively for the palliative of greater redistribution of wealth,10 and another that clings to a past that can’t be resuscitated.  The rise of populist politics, then, may just be getting warmed up.

This would seemingly be the last leg.  If sentiment that the country no longer offers opportunities for most Americans increases, politics could become more contentious and partisan, thereby inhibiting the ability of politicians to address the very problems they were elected to solve.11  This process of reflexivity would enable angers to fester, demagogues to emerge and people to call the system itself into question.12

Challenge and Response

The men of a given generation are generally unaware of the degree to which they envisage their contemporary history within an assumed framework, ranging events into certain shapes or running them into certain moulds which are sometimes adopted almost as in a day-dream.  They may be sublimely unconscious of the way their minds are constricted by their routine formulation of the story; and only when the World is different, and there emerges a new generation not locked from birth in the accepted framework, does the narrowness of that framework become apparent to everybody.13

But all this speaks to a failure of imagination.  The post-World War II economy was an anomaly—there’s no going back to the way things were.  And if that’s the case, should we expect leaders who came of age during that period of relative stability to come up with solutions to today’s problems?

I suspect not; the “assumed frameworks” are too rigid.  The generation coming of age, however, in an international system defined by entropy and whose economic prospects are much more uncertain may be more willing to take on the shibboleths that have constrained political progress.

In A Study of History, the historian Arnold J. Toynbee posited that civilizations rise and fall through a process of challenge and response.  I worry that the magnitude of the challenges have yet to be internalized; and I fear that the transition between accepting today’s world and adjusting to tomorrow’s—The Reckoning—could get turbulent; but I am cautiously optimistic that younger/future generations will respond to these challenges with ingenuity, catalyzing a political realignment that will lead to regeneration and prosperity.  We just can’t see it yet.

# # #


1 George Frost Kennan, Around the Cragged Hill (1993), pg. 101.

2 John Maynard Keynes, “Economic Possibilities for Our Grandchildren” (1930).  As quoted in Essays in Persuasion (1963), pgs. 358, 364.  Emphasis in original.

3 Grandma, January 15, 2014.

4 Through the 2000 dot-com bubble—until it crashed.  Then the surge back from 2004-2007—until it crashed.  And then the 2009-present alpine climb—which likely will crash at some point, even though nobody thinks it will.

5 Not an exhaustive list.

6 Social Security Administration, “Wage Statistics for 2012.”

7 This is a quote from Carroll Quigley’s Tragedy and Hope: A History of the World in Our Time (1966), pg. 342.  In context, the quote reads: “The economic effects of these soft prices after 1925 were adverse, but these effects were concealed for a considerable period because of various influences, especially the liberal credit policies of the United States (both foreign and domestic) and the optimism engendered by the stock-market boom.  The facade of prosperity over unsound economic conditions was practically worldwide.”

8 I think there’s room for this technology to foster distributed innovation/R&D, but I’m less convinced that it will take place at sufficient scale to offset the broader labor market trends.

10 “It is the lesson of history, after all, that every attempt at social leveling ends with leveling to the bottom, never to the top.” Kennan, op.cit., pg. 129.

11 Look no further than today’s Washington for an example.

12 This is all a bit gloomy of a prognosis.  I don’t think the path dependence is quite so strong, but this outcome strikes me as conceivable.  A correction of some variety seems inevitable.

13 Herbert Butterfield, Christianity and History (1949), pg. 140.  As quoted in Arnold J. Toynbee, A Study of History: Abridgment of Volumes VII-X by D.C. Somervell (1957), pg. 266.


13 responses to “The Reckoning”

  1. Favorite Books of 2018 | Mike Casey Avatar

    […] Butterfield, whom I discovered in a footnote in Toynbee’s A Study of History, has appeared several times on this blog. His musings constitute a veritable gift that keeps on […]

  2. A Reason for Optimism | Mike Casey Avatar

    […] four years ago, I wrote a post called “The Reckoning.” In it, I put forward the idea that unsustainable economic trends in the United States would […]

  3. The Death of Graduate School? | Un Passaggio Avatar

    […] blog has already covered U.S. households’ lack of savings and income growth; there’s no reason to believe that wages are keeping pace with the growth in tuition. Plainly, […]

  4. Fatherland | Un Passaggio Avatar

    […] The Reckoning | January 2014 […]

  5. Favorite Books of 2016 | Un Passaggio Avatar

    […] readers may have noticed that the vanishing of the American Dream is a topic that this blog has covered from time to time, including in the inaugural edition of the Favorite Books of 201X series. It’s […]

  6. Gethsemane | Un Passaggio Avatar

    […] The Reckoning | January 2014 […]

  7. Favorite Books of 2015 | Un Passaggio Avatar

    […] Kissinger’s book inspired a post of its own (see: Henry Kissinger’s World Order and the Question of Universal Values), but interested readers may also wish to peruse this blog’s pieces on Entropy: The Defining Characteristic of International Affairs, Politics and Culture in International History, and The Reckoning. […]

  8. QE & Inequality | Un Passaggio Avatar

    […] The Reckoning | January 2014 […]

  9. Entropy: The Defining Characteristic of Global Affairs | Un Passaggio Avatar

    […] not everyone has won from globalization. In The Reckoning, I laid out a few variables that indicated that life in the United States throughout the same […]

  10. The Squeeze Is On | Un Passaggio Avatar

    […] The Reckoning, I suggested that the decades-long squeeze on labor still has room to run, particularly in light of […]

Create a website or blog at